Quick Index
Design Criteria
Modes of Failure
Factor of Safety
Modes of Failure Illustrations
The L/D Limit
Environmental Effects
Temperature Effects
Sustained Loading Effects
Weathering Effects
Color and Aesthetics
Corrosion-Resistant Resin Systems
Chemical Effects
Contact Sales Representatives
Back to the Tuff Span Main Page
DESIGN CRITERIA

Fiberglass reinforced plastics as composite materials possess mechanical properties that each constituent cannot provide individually. These properties include high strength per weight, corrosion and fire resistance, and cost per performance advantage. We have designed the corrugated and ribbed sections of Tuff Span panels to provide efficient high strength, rigid, and economical structural components for use in industrial buildings.


Design parameters used to prepare the load/span tables are based on results from a series of large-scale tests. We test full-size corrugated panels under uniform and concentrated loading conditions using two span vacuum box and three point load tests. Test results are based on an ambient temperature of 77° F.

The critical stress at failure (e.g., maximum deflection (L/D) governs the allowable load and span of a panel section. Critical stress is limited by stability failure ( collapse of corrugations), material failure, or fastener pullover. Factors of safety are then applied judiciously to obtain the load/span relationship.
You should use these tables as a design guide only to help you select the most efficient and economical panel for a given load or span. The allowable load/span should be verified for each design by a qualified engineer, since the actual conditions of installation and use will vary.

These tables do not consider the effects of corrosive environments or elevated temperatures on panel strength or rigidity. You should reduce these factors appropriately, or apply an additional factor of safety to the expected loads, for such applications, especially where safety is a consideration

MODES OF FAILURE

Under service conditions, the primary modes of failure for panels are fastener pullover, web crippling, flange buckling, tension failures or compression failures. These modes are classified as either resin control or fiber control failures.

Fiber control failures can be tensile or compressive failures. They can also be failures caused by excessive deflection. Fiber control failures occur when the material does not provide sufficient strength and stiffness to the panel to withstand the applied loads.

Resin control failures occur when the deterioration of the resin binder weakens the material and causes structural failures. Chemical attack, water absorption, elevated temperatures, and creep can initiate the panel degradation.

Fastener pullover occurs when a panel under negative load pulls over the washer and screw head. The situation arises when there is a sufficient suction pressure, combined with internal pressure inside a building, to create failure at attachment points. Wind loading subjects a building to both the external pressures from the direct impact of the wind and the outward (negative or uplift) pressures created by an interaction of the air motion and the structure. It is essential to consider negative loads when specifying roofing and siding materials.

Material failure occurs when forces stress the panel material to its ultimate strength. This is the ideal mode of failure because it provides the greatest panel capacity. Web crippling and flange buckling are local instability failures that cause corrugations to collapse. The critical stresses at failure are smaller than the material ultimate stresses. Different panel sections yield different levels of critical stresses.


MODES OF FAILURE ILLUSTRATIONS

Accurate and reliable performance data is determined from large scale tests that simulate actual installations. Photos show materials tested to failure.

Click each to launch a full description & illustration window
Pullover - Punch Out Type Tests Pullover - Simulated Full Span Bending Test Compression Failure - Three Point Loading Test Web Crippling Failure - Vacuum Box Panel Loading Test Flange Buckling Failure - Vacuum Box Panel Loading Test

FACTOR OF SAFETY

A Factor of Safety (FOS), as employed for Tuff Span panels, is the ratio of the ultimate capacity to the allowable actual working capacity of the component. The FOS must consider many factors, including the degree of certainty and precision available for determining component mechanical properties, stress, and overall performance under loading conditions. It must also consider the deterioration due to environmental conditions, full-scale loading conditions, and all uncertainties that can contribute to the probability of failure as well as the degree of its consequences.

It should be noted that the design wind speeds specified in building codes may never be reached in the life of the structure. For this reason, most codes allow some reduction in the FOS for wind loading. If you need to determine the negative pressure created by wind loads, you should multiply the dynamic wind pressure by the shape factor as specified by the applicable building code. The panel tables are based on the FOS of 2.5 for live loads (other than wind) and 1.88 (75% of 2.5) for wind loads.

These Factors of Safety cover conditions for industrial buildings. Larger FOS should be applied in accordance with the nature of loading and actual service conditions.


THE L/D LIMIT

Fiberglass reinforced plastic has a relatively high strength to modulus ratio, and most FRP designs are deformation controlled rather than stress controlled. The ratio between the span length and its maximum deflection (L/D) gives the deflection ratio.

The value to which the span to deflection ratio (L/D) is limited is an important design criteria. The limit should be set with these factors in mind:

  • section shape,
  • section function as a structural component,
  • type of loading.
When the L/D limit is set too low, excessive panel deflection can cause enlarging of holes at fasteners. Hole enlargement will cause premature failure of the panel due to fastener pullover. Also, an L/D Limit that is sset too low will allow a panel to buffet during a windstorm and this may lead to a panel tearing and blowing off the building. Panel buffeting and excessive deflection will cause the breaking of seals between panels which can result in leaking.

The L/D limit as applied in these tables will prevent excessive span deflection and enlargement of the fastener holes

ENVIRONMENTAL EFFECTS

Strength properties of reinforced plastics are reduced under continuous exposure to elevated temperatures. And elevated temperatures can accelerate the effects on FRP of exposure to sustained load and hostile conditions (chemicals, moisture, ultraviolet rays, etc.).

Plastic based materials, more than other building materials, are susceptible to creep, especially at high service temperature. You should consider the effects of service environments on FRP when choosing the type of resin and reinforcing systems you need in your FRP structural components.


TEMPERATURE EFFECTS
The weakening effect of elevated temperature on FRP strength is temporary. As the panel temperature returns to normal so does the panel regain its strength.

When designing with Tuff Span products in applications with continuous elevated temperatures, the strength properties should be reduced using these guidelines.


Temperature °F Minimum Strength Properties Retention %
  Polyester Vinyl Ester
77 100 100
100 87 98
125 72 95
150 55 92
175 - 85
200 - 65
225 - 42
 Download a printable Adobe Acrobat (PDF) file version of this section

SUSTAINED LOADING EFFECTS

All plastic based components deform when they are subjected to a sustained load. Deformation continues indefinitely or, if the load is high enough, until rupture occurs. Tuff Span load/span tables contain Factors of Safety. When the tables are observed the possibility of rupture is eliminated.

We apply design and product considerations to keep the actual stress and strain levels within Tuff Span products under specific limits. This allows the control of creep to a satisfactory level during the service life of the product. Our tables reflect these considerations and are based on long-term testing of materials under sustained loads.



WEATHERING EFFECTS

Plastic based materials experience physical and appearance changes during exposure to weathering and ultraviolet rays. The following protective means are available for Tuff Span products:
  • U.V. stabilizers ( acrylic monomers, standard) are added to the resin system to retard weathering effects.
  • Surfacing mats (standard) are added to retard weathering and resist corrosion.
  • Surfacing veils (optional) are available for further weather and corrosion resistance.
  • Acrylic Polymer coatings are added as a finish coat to protect against damage due to ultraviolet rays.

COLOR AND AESTHETICS

You can use Tuff Span panels to create aesthetically pleasing designs. A number of standard colors are readily available, and custom colors can be created to match existing materials or color schemes.

Translucent panels are available also. Translucent panels admit daylight and so brighten work environments. This can contribute to worker safety and job satisfaction.

See the Material Description page for a listing of Tuff Span standard colors and light transmission factors.

Some product discoloration may occur under certain atmospheric and environmental conditions beyond our control. A stack of panels can trap heat and moisture that may cause clouding. See page 24 for correct storage and handling procedures.

Slight color variations may occur between production runs and between opaque and translucent panels in the same color. If color matching is critical, contact your sales engineer.


CORROSION-RESISTANT RESIN SYSTEMS

Chemical exposures and operating conditions vary widely from industry to industry. Because of this, Tuff Span panels are available in three resin systems. This allows you to tailor a Tuff Span panel to meet your specific needs.

Premium Grade Isophthalic Polyester Resins are recommended for environments exposed to splash and spill chemicals and moderate operating temperatures.

Vinyl Ester Resins are recommended for environments exposed to severe chemical condenses and high operating temperatures.

Series FM Polyester Resin has demonstrated excellent resistance to chemical attack from vapors and moderate condensates produced by certain acids and bases (see FM Resin Guide). Contact your Tuff Span Sales Engineers for recommendations on specific applications.

Series FM Exposure Guide
Chemical % Maximum Operating Temperature (°F)
of FM Polyester
Alum Vapor 120
Hydrochloric Acid Vapor 120
Sodium Hypochlorite Vapor 120
Sodium Hydroxide Vapor 120
Sulfuric Acid Vapor 120
 Download a printable Adobe Acrobat (PDF) file version of this section

CHEMICAL EFFECTS

It is important to consider the effects of corrosion on materials in the design stage. Many factors should be evaluated, including chemical type, concentration, type and duration of exposure, and operating temperature.

You should contact your Tuff Span sales engineer or our headquarters if you need a recommendation for a specific application. Also, we can help you select the appropriate materials for environments and exposures not covered in this Guide.


Chemical Maximum Operating Temperature (°F)
% ISO Polyester Vinyl Ester
Acetic Acid 10 150 210
Acetic Acid 50 125 180
Acetone All NR NR
Alum Vapor 150 210
Aluminum Sulfate 5 150 210
Aluminum Potassium Sulfate All 130 210
Ammonia - - 100
Ammonium Hydroxide 10 NR 160
Benzene All NR NR
Benzensulfonic Acid 30 NR 210
Bromine fumes NR 70
Calcium Chloride All 150 210
Carbon Tetrachloride Vapor 70 70
Chlorine (Gas Wet) All AMB 220
Chromic Acid 5 - 100
Cooling Tower Water - 130 170
Copper Sulfate All 120 210
Dibutyl Phthalaic 100 70 150
Ethylene Chlorohydrine All NR 100
Ethyline Dichloride All NR 100
Ethyl Ether All NR NR
Ethylene Glycol All 150 210
Ferrous Sulfate All 150 210
Fatty Acids 100 150 210
Flousilicic Acid 10 100 150
Fungicides, Organic - 125 -
Gasoline 100 100 100
Hydrochloric Acid 1 150 210
Hydrochloric Acid 15 150 210
Hydrochloric Acid 32 90 180
Hydrochloric Acid Vapor 150 210
Hydrogen Chloride (Gas) 100 120 210
Hydrogen Sulfide All 140 210
Kerosene/Fuel Oil 100 150 180
Magnesium Chloride 100 150 210
Methyl Alcohol 100 AMB NR
Mineral Oil 100 150 200
Naptha 100 150 180
Nitric Acid 5 150 150
Nitric Acid 60 NR 160
Phosphoric Acid 10 - 210
Phosphoric Acid 30 - 210
Phosphoric Acid 85 150 210
Potassium aluminum Sulfate SATD 130 210
Sodium Bicarbonate 10 120 180
Sodium Bisulfate All 150 210
Sodium Carbonate All 70 160
Sodium Chloride SATD 150 210
Sodium Hydroxide 5 NR 150
Sodium Hydroxide Vapor 150 180
Sodium Hypochlorite 5 120 150
Sodium Hypochlorite Vapor 150 150
Sodium Nitrate All 150 210
Sodium Silicate All NR 210
Sodium Sulfate All 150 210
Soya Oil 100 130 180
Styrene 100 NR NR
Sulfite Liquors - 120 210
Sulfur Dioxide Dry 150 210
Sulfur Dioxide Wet 150 210
Sulfur Trioxide 100 AMB 210
Sulfuric Acid 25 120 210
Sulfuric Acid 50 NR 210
Sulfuric Acid 70 NR 160
Sulfuric Acid Vapor 150 210
Trisodium Phosphate 25 - 210
Water Distilled 100 140 210
Water (city/sea) 100 150 210
Zinc Sulfate All 150 210
Design engineers and plant personnel should use this Guide as an aid in the selection of an appropriate resin system for their specific application. Since specific job applications will vary, this information should be used as a guide only and it cannot be considered a guarantee of performance.

The Polyester and Vinyl Ester chemical resistance guide is to be used for standard Tuff Span isophthalic polyester and vinyl ester fire-rated panels only. The resin system for the Series FM material is a specially formulated isophthalic polyester with specific additives for enhanced fire retardance. The chemical resistance of Tuff Span Series FM polyester should not be considered the same as standard isophthalic polyester or vinyl ester.
Download a printable Adobe Acrobat (PDF) file version of this section
 Back to the Tuff Span main page
 Download a printable Adobe Acrobat version of this entire page